Stefanina's Pizzeria Reviews

The pizza tasted good , and the delivery was fine , but the toppings felt a little uneven to me . A few slices had a decent amount , while others were mostly just cheese and sauce .

It definitely wasn’t bad , I just expected a bit more for the price . I might order again , but next time I’d probably ask for extra toppings .

The slices were huge, and I left feeling full. Definitely a good amount of food

The staff were super friendly and really easy to chat with, which made the visit feel nice right away. The pizza was good too, not totally perfect, but still enjoyable. Overall, it was a nice little place and I’d come back again. What’s not to like??

I felt a little relieved when I saw how many choices were on the menu. We were with a group, and that can be stressful when everyone likes different things, but everyone ended up finding something they were excited about and enjoyed.

I tried the pizza and it was okay, just not really anything special. The crust was fine and the cheese was good, but the flavor felt kind of plain, like it needed more seasoning or a stronger sauce. I kept eating it because I was hungry and already had it in front of me, but I felt a little stuck with something I wasn’t that excited about. Not bad, just not the kind of pizza I’d find myself craving again.

Ordered from stefspizza.com and I’ll give them credit, the food did show up on time. The annoying part was the pizza was barely warm when we opened the box, definitely not hot like you’d expect. I also tried asking about the delivery timing and got a couple different answers, which was kind of frustrating because it felt like nobody was really on the same page.

The flavor was fine and the toppings were decent, so it wasn’t a total miss. But eating lukewarm pizza is just disappointing, and I ended up putting a few slices in the oven to make it better. Overall, not terrible, but between the cold-ish pizza and the inconsistent answers, I wouldn’t say I was impressed.

I ordered from stefspizza.com and everything showed up exactly how I asked for it!! Extra toppings were there, no onions like I requested, and even the sauces made it in the bag. Happy about that since those little details are usually where places mess up :)

The pizza was good. Tasty. The flavor was there and I enjoyed it, but the prices felt a bit higher than I expected. Ouch. I’d probably still go back, just not all the time.

The crust was a little too chewy for my taste. It wasn’t bad, but it just felt...

The service was alright for me, kind of hit or miss honestly. The person I talked with was nice enough, but getting a clear answer about my order took longer than I expected. Not terrible or anything, just a little slow and not very organized it felt. I might order again, but faster replies next time would be really nice.

It showed up way quicker than I was expecting. Maybe I just assumed the shipping would take longer, but I was surprised when it got here so fast.

Stopped in here and the place looked clean. The tables seemed wiped down, the floor wasn’t gross or anything, and the counter area looked like they actually keep up with it.

The bathroom was decent too, which I always kinda notice when I’m eating somewhere. It wasn’t perfect-perfect, but it was totally fine and not something that made me wanna leave lol.

Overall I felt comfortable eating there and didnt have any real complaints. Just a clean, easy stop and I’d be okay going back again.

I ordered from stefspizza.com for pickup because I’d been out running a couple errands and really didn’t feel like making dinner when I got home. The order was ready right when I got there, which was nice because I still had groceries sitting in the car. The staff was friendly, the box was hot, and the pizza tasted really good. Everything in the order was right, no problems at all. I’ll probably order again next time I’m not in the mood to cook

Grabbed a pizza last night the veggies tasted really fresh, not all soggy like they sometimes can be. The cheese was good too, kind of just hit the spot. Nothing too fancy, but it was simple and really solid. I’d probably order it again.

I’ve ordered this pizza a few times, and for the most part it’s been decent. I kind of assume it depends on who’s working that day because every now and then it tastes a little different, but usually it’s okay